Singapore and Munich have developed very different entrepreneurial ecosystems. One is a small city-state whose startups must look internationally almost from the outset. The other is embedded in one of Europe's most established industrial regions, with access to engineering expertise, manufacturers and specialised suppliers.
Yet both face a similar challenge: turning world-class research and promising startups into globally competitive companies.
During a visit to Singapore, I spoke with Dr Tan Sian Wee, Senior Vice President (Innovation & Enterprise) at the National University of Singapore (NUS), and Professor Helmut Schönenberger, co-founder and CEO of UnternehmerTUM and Vice President for Entrepreneurship at the Technical University of Munich (TUM), about what their respective ecosystems can learn from each other.
Both bring experience that extends well beyond academia.
Dr Tan joined NUS in January 2025 after a career spanning Silicon Valley, Europe and Asia. A Stanford-trained mechanical engineer, he was an early investor and pioneer of haptic technology at Immersion, where he holds 10 patents. He subsequently developed a research spinout programme for Germany's Fraunhofer Society, advised Israeli technology company PrimeSense, and held venture capital and fintech leadership roles in Singapore, including at Monk's Hill Ventures and Finaxar.
Professor Schönenberger also began his career in engineering, studying aerospace engineering at the University of Stuttgart before pursuing management studies at TUM. His research comparing Stanford's entrepreneurial ecosystem with Munich helped inspire the creation of UnternehmerTUM in 2002. He has since built the organisation into a major European startup and innovation centre, combining university research, industry collaboration, venture capital and company creation.
Their careers share a common thread: both have worked to bridge the gap between scientific research and commercial businesses. Both also have experience across European and international innovation ecosystems, including connections to Silicon Valley.
The conversations followed the announcement of a new partnership between NUSX and UnternehmerTUM, connecting founders, researchers, investors and industrial partners across Singapore and Munich.
Beyond the formal agreement, both leaders see an opportunity to rethink how deeptech companies are built and scaled internationally.
Connecting students, startups and investors across continents
The NUSX–UnternehmerTUM partnership builds on an existing relationship between the two universities. Since the establishment of NUS Overseas Colleges (NOC) Munich in 2017, nearly 120 NUS students and more than 90 TUM students have participated in exchanges between Singapore and Munich.
The new collaboration aims to extend these opportunities beyond student exchanges into venture creation, investment and international expansion, initially focusing on biotechnology, AI and semiconductors. Through the partnership, Singaporean students will gain access to European industry partners, technical expertise and opportunities to validate their technologies with potential customers.
UnternehmerTUM, through TUM Venture Labs, is also exploring a presence at NUS's i³ building in Singapore, giving Munich-based founders access to Singapore's startup ecosystem and potential partners and markets across Asia.
The partnership also aims to strengthen investment links, with NUS in discussions with a Munich-based VC firm affiliated with UnternehmerTUM about joining its S$150 million venture capital programme.
Singapore's advantage: Speed and an international mindset
For Dr Tan, one of Singapore's greatest advantages is its ability to make decisions and implement policy relatively quickly. "I think the decision cycles here are faster," he said, particularly at the political level.
He pointed to Singapore's relatively straightforward business registration process, contrasting it with the administrative procedures entrepreneurs can encounter in Germany.
According to Dr Tan, Singapore's small domestic market has always required it to look beyond its borders, fostering an international outlook and a willingness to collaborate across different ecosystems. "Historically, we've acted as a bridge between East and West, and today that extends to people, ideas, technologies and business opportunities," he explained.
"We're exposed to different cultures, markets and ways of doing business. That diversity allows us to identify commercial opportunities that might not be immediately obvious elsewhere."
Professor Schönenberger sees this international orientation as a major attraction.
"Singapore is always on top and from a European perspective, it's a perfect gateway to Asia," he said.
However, Dr Tan cautioned against assuming that successful innovation models can simply be transplanted from one country to another.
"We don't believe in copying, we believe in copying and smart pasting," he said.
That means considering the cultural context, geopolitical environment and maturity of an ecosystem before adopting practices developed elsewhere.
The same principle applies to Singaporean companies entering international markets, where differences in customer expectations, purchasing power and infrastructure may require significant changes to products and business models. Europe's challenge:
Finding the capital to scale
Dr Tan believes Singapore's relative youth also gives it greater flexibility to adapt than Europe's more established institutional and cultural structures. However, he argues Europe could make significant progress without major structural reforms by directing more institutional capital towards venture investment.
"The fastest thing that you can do is actually reallocate your capital just a little bit," he argued.
He pointed to Europe's substantial pools of institutional capital, including pension and insurance funds, and questioned why more of that money was not being directed towards venture investment. Professor Schönenberger similarly sees the challenge shifting from company formation towards later-stage growth.
"The challenges move to the later stage," he said.
"How do we get this growth capital?"
He also believes Europe should have greater confidence in its own entrepreneurs.
"As Europeans, we should also believe in our European kids," he said.
By contrast, Dr Tan points to Singapore's long-term approach to managing national reserves and investing in research as an example of how a small country can build substantial technological capabilities. Singapore has established strengths in semiconductors, pharmaceutical manufacturing, defence technologies and services.
Dr Tan estimates that the country produces around 10 to 15 per cent of the world's advanced chips. Over approximately three decades, Singapore has invested a cumulative €60 billion in research and development, helping establish its research infrastructure and train generations of scientists.
"We're now reaching a stage where we're increasingly sophisticated about translating scientific research into outcomes that benefit society," he said.
"Every year, NUS generates thousands of invention disclosures. Within those could be the next 10 big companies, hundreds of licensing deals or new industrial partnerships."
Why Munich's industrial base matters
One of Munich's advantages is its proximity to major industrial companies, including BMW, Siemens and Airbus, alongside a network of specialised engineering businesses and suppliers.
Unlike software startups, companies building rockets, fusion reactors or advanced manufacturing systems require complex supply chains, specialised components and access to engineering expertise. The availability of those capabilities within a relatively concentrated geographical area can significantly accelerate development.
Dr Tan identified precisely this industrial connectivity as a reason for choosing UnternehmerTUM as a partner. He highlighted "the industrial strengths and the sheer connectivity" into Europe's industrial base, arguing that this offered something more valuable than access to a narrowly specialised innovation hub.
He was also attracted by UnternehmerTUM's operating model, which generates approximately 60 per cent of its funding through innovation consulting, with government grants and donations each contributing around 20 per cent.
The model offers an alternative to innovation organisations that rely predominantly on public funding, combining commercial relationships with government and philanthropic support.
What Europe can learn from Singapore
Professor Schönenberger believes Europe could also learn from Singapore's approach to long-term planning. "What we can learn from Singapore is strategic long-term thinking," he said.
"Have the vision and then execute it."
He argued that Europe needs a similarly coordinated approach to technologies such as satellite communications, affordable energy, fusion and computing.
"Sometimes it takes three or four years, but in the long run, this is not a long time span," he said.
Turning research into commercial opportunities
For NUS, international collaboration is also part of a wider effort to improve research commercialisation. Dr Tan described the enormous volume of inventions and research emerging from the university, and the challenge of identifying which technologies have genuine commercial potential. "Commercialisation is product-market fit," he said.
"When you have just a pure technology push, the inventors will always say this is good for A, B and C. But the market may disagree."
A successful invention does not automatically translate into a successful company. Researchers may lack the market knowledge, commercial networks or entrepreneurial experience needed to identify customers and develop viable businesses.
To address this, NUSX has developed Nova with Zima Labs, an AI-powered platform designed to match university research and intellectual property with potential commercial partners.
The system draws on more than 20,000 NUS patents and invention disclosures, 9,000 research projects and 11,000 inventors, combining university data with external information about companies, investors and market needs.
For Dr Tan, the aim is not simply to produce more patents or startups, but to improve the likelihood that university research finds commercially viable applications.
NUS also operates a S$150 million venture capital programme designed to connect its research and startups with experienced investors and company-building expertise. Its partners include Playground Global, Granite Asia and Matter Venture Partners.
These relationships are valuable not only because they provide capital, but because investors can help researchers identify commercial applications, develop prototypes and build businesses.
Why interdisciplinary innovation creates stronger companies
Dr Tan also sees interdisciplinary innovation as essential to developing technologies that competitors cannot easily replicate. NUS is sending engineering teams to Stanford to learn product development approaches, from identifying customer needs and building prototypes to designing for manufacturing and commercial scale.
With donor support, up to four teams are expected to participate this year, and the university will gradually incorporate these methods into its own programmes.
"If you take something from computing, something from engineering and something from biology, you create much greater defensibility."
. He describes this approach as defence in depth, where combining expertise across disciplines makes technologies more difficult to reproduce.
"There's no such thing as absolute protection. There's only delay. You want to make sure you create the longest possible delays."
From international internships to startup founders
For Dr Tan, one of the most valuable aspects of international student exchanges is the opportunity to experience different entrepreneurial cultures firsthand. When students from universities such as TUM come to Singapore, they quickly discover that products, services and business models need to be adapted to local markets.
They also encounter the pace and demands of working in a startup, helping them decide whether entrepreneurship is a career they want to pursue.
NUS has been sending students to Silicon Valley for startup internships for approximately two decades, with striking results.
"Our data shows that approximately 40 per cent of those participants have subsequently started their own companies," Dr Tan said.
Stockholm recorded the second-highest rate, with approximately 36 per cent of participants going on to become founders. The figures suggest a strong association between international startup experience and subsequent entrepreneurship, although they do not establish that the internships alone caused students to start businesses.
"Many students don't fully understand what working in a startup involves until they experience it themselves," he explained.
NUS is also looking to expand students' exposure to China's technology ecosystem, particularly its consumer technology sector.
"The speed and scale of innovation there are remarkable," he said.
His longer-term ambition is to give students the opportunity to experience contrasting entrepreneurial environments, potentially spending six months in Europe or Silicon Valley and another six months in China.
"That would allow them to experience different entrepreneurial cultures and decide which environments best suit their ambitions."
For Dr Tan, these experiences are not simply about developing technical or commercial skills. They expose students to different approaches to innovation, market expectations and company-building, while creating international relationships that can remain valuable long after their internships end.
Bringing the European Defence Tech Hackathon to Singapore
NUS's partnership with the European Defence Tech Hackathon was initially conceived as a relatively modest event, but international interest quickly exceeded expectations.
"We thought we'd have about 150 sign-ups. Within six months, we had more than 1,000 registrations from around the world," Dr Tan said.
The event also attracted international mentors and 23 sponsors, reflecting growing interest in defence innovation and cross-border collaboration. For Dr Tan, defence innovation is closely connected to Singapore's economic development and national security.
"People take it for granted that prosperity comes from working hard and achieving something. But the necessary precondition for prosperity is stability."
He argues that Singapore's long-standing emphasis on defence has helped create the conditions for economic growth, while changing security threats require new approaches to technology development.
"The threats of tomorrow are not the threats of the Cold War. We need to think differently."
Dr Tan also sees considerable value in bringing international defence innovators together to test technologies in different operating environments.
A system developed for Ukraine's climate and battlefield conditions, for example, may perform very differently in Singapore's tropical environment, where humidity, equipment degradation and communications challenges add complications.
Beyond technical testing, he believes the greatest benefit is the opportunity for participants to exchange ideas, develop new approaches and form international teams.
"By combining people from all around the world, you get the best ideas."
Two ecosystems, complementary strengths
Singapore cannot replicate the industrial scale of southern Germany, while Munich cannot reproduce Singapore's geographical position or its role as a gateway to Asian markets. But that is exactly what makes the partnership interesting.
For Professor Schönenberger, Europe should have confidence in its existing strengths while remaining internationally connected.
"Let's, as Europeans, focus on our strengths as one of the greatest research ecosystems we have, industrial ecosystems we have, and then stay hungry and open," he said. Dr Tan similarly sees Singapore as a potential bridge between European and Asian innovation ecosystems. "We'd love to work with the ecosystem of people in Europe," he said.
For Europe, the challenge is mobilising the capital and industrial capacity to scale its innovations. For Singapore, it is ensuring that research and entrepreneurial talent can access markets far beyond its borders.
Rather than competing to replicate each other's strengths, the two ecosystems are betting that deeper connections will help founders build companies capable of competing globally.
Would you like to write the first comment?
Login to post comments